Manual or Automatic Trading Robot

Manual or Automatic trading robot - what makes more money in 2018 - 2019

What makes more money, manual trading or automated trading? Okay, so which method is more profitable, manual or automated trading? Now look, this question comes up a lot, and I want to share my opinion on it, as I know that it is, indeed, a very hot topic.

Firstly, let's take a step back and analyze both methods from a top-down perspective.

So by definition, Manual or discretionary trading means to place, manage, and close a trade with human intervention. Simply put, that means you're sitting at your computer or on your mobile, opening and closing your trade by the click of a mouse. Everything from why, when, and how much you trade is solely down to your discretion. Now, it's also important to note here that the rules you live by as a manual trader should be mechanical. Now, that's not to confuse the definition, but what I mean by this is that you're basing your trades on back-tested strategies. That's to say, you're scanning and methodically executing your trades just as you've tested in your back-testing. Else if you don't well, then you don't have a strategy.

Now, on the other hand, you have the automated trading. Now, you may also hear this referred to as algo trading or trading with a robot (That’s me:D). Now, in our world, this is done commonly with the help of technical analysis software like Omni Trader, Metastock, Ninja Trader, Metatrader4 or Metatrader5 etc.  And it's known or often referred to as a Strategy set or Expert Advisor (this vary program to program you are using, but the working is same in all program). So, an expert advisor or a Strategy set is a program that allows you to execute your programming logic or the trading strategy that trades for you. Now, what this means is that you're trading with the help of a computer. This makes the decisions on your behalf based on the programming logic that you’ve programmed in. Now, the algorithm by definition means a process or set of rules to be followed in calculation or other programming solving operations, especially by a computer think of this as, though, you're telling the computer what you would do manually, but in code.

But there lied the additional challenge-coding. Now, you can outsource for programmers to write up the logic for you, but there are risks for that. How do you really know its accuracy? How do you know it's doing what you expect and that there aren't any bugs? I mean, you can backtest the logic to see the performance, but what if you're looking for something to just flag signals that you then trade manually? How do you know if it's doing what you think it should be, every single time when you have no back-tested data.

 Now, on the other hand, you can set yourself the challenge by learning how to program and write some code yourself. Although, I can tell you that is not a small feat by itself. Learning how to trade, a folk, consistently profitable, is like learning a degree. Programming what you've learned manually to code is like learning two degrees. So, it goes without saying that, learning and then programming a strategy in the forex market is definitely a lot longer path if you're doing this with no prior knowledge.

But the question you really want to know is which method is more profitable? Well, certainly there are advantages and disadvantages to both methods. But I think it's pretty accurate to say that the hardest challenge that many manual traders find when starting off, is the psychology behind it all. You know, it's the inability to keep rational, and calm in losing periods, as well as the profitable periods. The traders are often unable to follow the simple set of rules. This ultimately leads to the destruction of many trading accounts. Now, in this case, automation may be the preferred option.

But then again, think about this, if you are unable to follow your own rules using manual trading is it going to be any different when trading with a robot? Are you going to start doubting the robot when it starts losing money? Are you going to tweak it because you go into drawdown?

Now, the other thing you need to think about is this, market conditions are constantly shifting. Changes in world events are often unpredictable. And a robot simply isn't able to react as well as a human can in these circumstances. Also, consider this; trading manually can be time-consuming. Not only in your backtesting but also in live trading and many traders when they start off their trading journey, still have day jobs. So are unable to spend countless hours at the screens, and remember learning to trade and trading does indeed, require a lot of screen time.

Look, the short answer is this, there's no real difference to your bottom line, with your trading automated or with your training manual. But it's more in how you execute your trading plan and the logic behind your trading plan. If your trading plan is absolute to the point and its making profit then I suggest you to create the robot version of it and save your time setting into the screen. This way you can concentrate on the other trading strategy you can make and backtest them to see how it works.  Think of this, if your trading plan or strategy is flawed in the first place, then it really doesn't matter if you're trading manually or with the use of a robot. And if your training logic or strategy is based on martingale or a good system, then again, when you trade this manually or algorithmically, then you're poised to blow up the trading account.

And as for purchasing an expert advisor or robot, well, I can talk about that until I'm blowing in the face on the topic. But in short, all I ask you to think about is this:  Why is the user selling their expert advisor for a few hundred dollars if it can supposedly make money from the market?

 Now, in this day and age a lot of retail traders, and I think it will continue going this way into the future, are trading using a hybrid of both routes. For example, you might have an expert advisor which again is on OmniTrader scanning for a specific price action setup, This then notifies you when one is found using the signal from the system you have programmed. You can then place and manage the trade manually from there on in. Now plenty of traders use automation in this regard to be more efficient. And it also it lowers the chances of missing trades, as well. This can be very detrimental, considering, it may be that one trade that you miss that turned out to be the huge winner.

Now, this is something that our teams are working on constantly behind the scenes. Now as traders, we're constantly researching the markets; looking for recurring inefficiencies at a price to exploit for our long-term goals. It's what gives us an edge over the rest within the industry. And in doing so, we found ways to lower human error and improve trading efficiency. We do this by developing a specific strategy that scans the markets, finding trade, foster trade manually or automatically. It's a critical part of our processes in some of the strategies that we deploy. To give you specific examples, we currently have two major strategies they’re Elliott wave and Time price & patterns. And the back testing on this so far is looking very promising, indeed, with some fantastic results which is available in our YouTube channel.  

So Moral of the blog is: if your strategy( Find here) is profitable then Manual or automatic trading both are profitable, But of course robot has some advantages over manual trading.

I hope you enjoyed the blog. I hope you found it useful!  Leave a comment as well, below with your opinion.  Find and follow us in all popular social media for latest and upcoming topic. Good luck with your trading!


Tags: AmpleTrader-The Robotic Trader


This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. The purpose using such materials vis-à-vis logos, names, taglines of any organization such As Microsoft, PayPal, Master Card, Rupay etc. are purely insisted to make experience more user friendly. does not claim any proft or illegal gains by using such materials.

Leave a Comment